How do Galaxies and SMBHs form and evolve in the First Billion years of the Universe?

JWST has revealed an uncharted territory of the Universe and posed new challenges to theoretical models for galaxy formation & origin of SMBHs.

The first deep field observed by the James Webb Space Telescope Interacting galaxies observed by the James Webb Space Telescope A second view of interacting galaxies observed by the James Webb Space Telescope
Copyright @NASA

High-redshift galaxies in light of JWST

High-redshift galaxies will obviously be a hot topic of astrophysical research in the next decade, with the development of key observational instruments (e.g. JWST, Roman). These open up new opportunities in understanding the formation and evolution of first generation of galaxies in the Universe, as well as new channels to study and constrain fundamental physics.

Projects

Non-equilibrium view of galaxies at Cosmic Dawn

During its Early-Science and Cycle-1 observations, the JWST uncovered an unexpectedly high number of UV-bright galaxies at the cosmic dawn. This discovery challenges many established theoretical models of galaxy formation. We suggested that the overlooked variability in galaxy UV luminosity, due to e.g. episodic star formation, may resolve this tension. Our proposition is compatible with the current galaxy formation framework and is grounded in plausible physical phenomena. Since its introduction, this theory has garnered significant interest in the scientific community, with numerous groups exploring its validity. Working in tandem with the FIRE simulation group, we became the first to verify the effectiveness of this concept. This is also the first simulation that reproduces the abundance of UV bright galaxies found by JWST. The bursty star-formation in particular has many more implications on the morphological diversity, chemical enrichment patterns, and escape of ionizing photons of early galaxies.

Shen+2023 Sun, Shen+2023 Hopkins, Shen+2023

High-redshift Predictions from IllustrisTNG

A series of papers on high-redshift galaxies, based on the IllustrisTNG simulation, the dust radiative transfer calculation using SKIRT and a dust model calibrated with compiled UV luminosity function data at z=4–10. In Paper I, we presented this framework for mock JWST predictions from simulations, and made predictions on the UV luminosity functions and the JWST NIRCam apparent band luminosity functions. In Paper II, we made predictions on the emission line luminosity functions (Hα, O[III]), spectral indices (D4000) and dust attenuation curves of high-redshift galaxies. In Paper III, we extended the prediction to FIR wavelengths, with a more realistic treatment of dust grain size distribution and non-local thermal effects.

Vogelsberger, Shen+2020) Shen+2020 Shen+2022

Alternative Cosmological Models

Early Universe is also an interesting test ground for physics beyond the standard LCDM framework. For example, many models imply modifications to the small-scale power spectrum of cosmic density fluctuations, which will inevitably affect the assembly of early galaxies. We have experimented with warm dark matter and the SIDM model with dark acoustic oscillations in a small-volume simulation within the THESAN simulation framework. Notably, the simulations include the recipe for sourcing ionizing photons, on-the-fly radiative transfer calculations and a hydrogen chemical-solver for reionization, which allow us to study the interplay between non-equilibrium reionization process and alternative dark matter physics. More recently, we have studied a cosmological model with early dark energy. It acts a potential joint solution to the Hubble tension and many puzzles regarding bright and massive galaxies found by JWST.

Shen+2023 Shen+2026

The THESAN-ZOOM Campaign

THESAN-ZOOM is a new suite of cosmological radiation-hydrodynamic zoom-in simulations targeting galaxies at z>3. It includes a wide array of physics build upon the SMUGGLE galaxy formation model that can resolve the explicit star-formation and feedback processes in a multiphase interstellar medium. THESAN-ZOOM further coupled it with on-the-fly radiative transfer and non-equilibrium thermo-chemistry along with, for the first time, fully self-consistent treatment of local ionizing photon background during the epoch of reionization. I have been a core member of the project and led the first wave of analyses on star-formation efficiencies in early galaxies. Universal star-formation laws emerge from these simulations with lots of implications for JWST observations.

Intro Paper (Kannan+2025) Shen+2025 Wang, Shen+2025

The Lumina Campaign

Lumina is a large-volume cosmological radiation-hydrodynamic simulation of our universe spanning the epoch of hydrogen and helium reionization with more than half a trillion resolution elements. It is one of the largest hydrodynamic simulation ever achieved and is the first to self-consistently model hundreds of millions of galaxies and supermassive black holes (SMBHs) along with their impact on the intergalactic medium. In one of the first release papers of Lumina, I present an semi-empirical model to explain the demographics of active galactic nuclei (AGN) at z>=3, including the mysterious Little Red Dots uncovered by JWST.

Intro Paper (Zier+2026) Shen+2026

SMBHs (AGN) in the early Universe

Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are believed to play a crucial role in the evolution of galaxies and the Universe. When accreting matter, they manifest as the so-called active galactic nuclei (AGN) or quasars. These are the most luminous objects in the Universe and can cast non-trivial impact on the evolution of host galaxies and the phase transition of the entire Universe. However, the origin of these SMBHs is still a mystery and we could hopefully find the answer through observations of AGN at high redshifts.

Projects

Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Functions

We have compiled a large dataset of quasar luminosity function measurements in far-UV, optical, X-ray, IR bands, and through emission lines in the past four decades. The observational data is paired with an updated quasar SED model, an updated extinction model based on the hydrogen column density distribution in Ueda et al. 2014 and a new bolometric correction function. We construct a new model for the bolometric quasar luminosity function that extends out to redshift 7. A public tool is available for computing bolometric/observed band luminosity functions of quasars across a wide redshift range. The evolutionary pattern of the bolometric QLF can be interpreted as an early phase likely dominated by the hierarchical assembly of structures and a late phase likely dominated by the quenching of galaxies. In a recent paper, I present an amendment of this model to include the Little Red Dots uncovered by JWST and fit them into a unified framework for cosmological evolution of AGN.

Shen+2020 Shen+2026

Seeding SMBHs with Dissipative SIDM

Together with Huangyu Xiao at Fermi Lab, we consider the seeding of supermassive black holes (SMBHs) in the early Universe with dissipative dark matter. Our study showed that, with appropriate choice of parameters, a hit-and-stick type of dissipative dark matter (e.g. asymmetric dark matter nuggets) can collapse to massive SMBH seeds in rare, massive haloes, which could be the progenitors for the observed billion solar mass quasars at z≳7. This exotic seeding scenario will give rise to completely different assembly history of early SMBHs and quasar activities. We are exploring the observational signatures in a follow-up study.

Xiao & Shen 2021 Shen T. & Shen 2025